[Ngo-sanrm] FW: E-Rice Monitor 20/2012: All GM field trials in India to be stopped
Sustainable Agriculture and Natural Resources Management Working Group
ngo-sanrm at ngocentre.org.vn
Thu Oct 25 11:31:31 ICT 2012
FYI
*From:*Morana Lefilliatre [mailto:morana.lefilliatre at panap.net]
*Sent:* Wednesday, 24 October, 2012 8:25 AM
*To:* "Undisclosed-Recipient:;"@gateway11.websitewelcome.com
<mailto:%22Undisclosed-Recipient:;%22 at gateway11.websitewelcome.com>
*Subject:* E-Rice Monitor 20/2012: All GM field trials in India to be
stopped
/#Apologies for any cross postings/
//
Best regards
Mona
PAN AP
*All GM field trials in India to be stopped
*
http://gmwatch.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=14328:all-gm-field-trials-in-india-to-be-stopped
<http://gmwatch.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=14328:all-gm-field-trials-in-india-to-be-stopped>
The Coalition for a GM-Free India, 18 October 2012
//
*10-year Moratorium on field trials of Bt food crops
*Moratorium on field trials of Herbicide Tolerant crops (till
independent assessment of impact and suitability) and
*Ban on field trials of GM crops for which India is a Centre of
Origin/Diversity
In an Interim Report signed off on 7th October 2012
(D.No.1944/2005/SC/PIL in the Assistant Registrar PIL (WRIT)'s office,
dated 17th October 2012), a 5-member Technical Expert Committee (TEC)
appointed by the Supreme Court of India in the Writ Petition (Civil) No.
260 of 2005, with Aruna Rodrigues and others as the petitioners in a PIL
pertaining to GMOs (Genetically Modified Organisms), unanimously
presented its view that all field trials should be stopped until the
following conditions have been met:
i) Specific sites for conducting field trials have been designated and
certified and sufficient mechanisms for monitoring the trials put in place.
ii) A panel of scientists, qualified in evaluation of the biosafety data
of GM crops has been engaged for scrutiny and analyses of the safety data.
iii) Conflict of interest in the regulatory body has been removed (as
discussed above).
iv) The requirement for preliminary biosafety tests prior to field
trials including sub-chronic toxicity in small animals has been included.
More importantly, the TEC recommended the following with regard to
certain classes of products:
9. Based on the current overall status of food safety evaluation of Bt
transgenics including the data on Bt cotton and Bt brinjal examined by
the TEC and in accordance with the precautionary principle, the TEC
recommends a ten year moratorium on field trials of Bt transgenics in
all food crops (those used directly for human consumption).
10. In view of the concerns bearing on health, environmental and
socio-economic considerations, the TEC recommends a moratorium on field
trials of herbicide tolerant (HT) crops until an independent committee
comprising of experts and stakeholders has examined and assessed the
potential impact of HT technology and its suitability in the Indian context.
11. India is a signatory to the Cartagena Protocol which recognises the
crucial importance of biodiversity as a long term resource. The TEC
accordingly recommends a ban on field trials of transgenics in those
crops for which India is a centre of origin or a centre of diversity, as
transgenics can contaminate and adversely affect the biodiversity.
The TEC specifically recommended for a re-examination of all biosafety
data for applications in process as well as those that have been
approved for release by scientists who are qualified in biosafety
science and experienced in evaluation of biosafety dossiers for
transgenic plants. Citing its rationale as "given the findings of the
TEC that there have been several cases of ignoring problematic aspects
of the data in the safety dossiers", the Committee recommended that the
re-examination, "if necessary, be done by international experts who have
the necessary experience".
It also recommended long term and inter-generational studies in rodents
to be added to the tests and performed for all products whether already
approved or yet to be approved.
Further, "acute and sub-chronic feeding studies for all applications
including those in progress should be completed before BRLI, as also
molecular analysis and allergenicity tests. If these studies indicate
potential risks of any kind, the GM event should be rejected outright to
save time, resources and contamination", the report said.
"Genome-wide expression analysis in the toxicity studies of the test
organism (eg. rodent) that is being exposed helps to identify changes in
biomarkers that are indicative of toxicity. This is an important test to
be included as biomarkers are sensitive indicators and are capable of
revealing changes before visible symptoms appear" read specific
recommendation 4 of the TEC.
For BRLI and BRL II trials, "the regulator needs to designate and
certify a defined number of sites in different parts of the country. All
field trials should be carried out only at these sites. These sites
should be used only for growing GM plants and not the non-GM material.
Trials should not be conducted in farmers' fields. This also applies to
those trials for which permission may have previously been given by the
regulator", the TEC stated.
YOU CAN DOWNLOAD THE TECHNICAL EXPERT COMMITTEE'S INTERIM REPORT HERE.
http://indiagminfo.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/SC-TEC-interim-report-oct17th-2012-GMO-PIL.pdf
THE SUPREME COURT ORDER SETTING UP THE TEC, ITS CONSTITUTION AND ITS
TERMS OF REFERENCE CAN BE DOWNLOADED HERE.
http://indiagminfo.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/2012_STPLWeb_294_SC.pdf
The Coalition for a GM-Free India welcomes this interim report from the
Technical Expert Committee set up by the apex court of India and awaits
the Supreme Court's hearing on the 29th of October 2012 in the matter.
While earlier inquiries and debates have been discounted by GM
proponents as 'political', or 'emotional', or 'non-scientific' inquiries
and recommendations/decisions, it is worth noting that the TEC consists
only of scientists, including of scientists from the government as its
representatives. Further, 22 of the 31 submissions studied by the TEC in
their nearly 4-month-long inquiry/study were from people with scientific
background.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://ngocentre.org.vn/pipermail/ngo-sanrm/attachments/20121025/33318710/attachment-0024.html
More information about the Ngo-sanrm
mailing list